Close Menu
    What's Hot

    Virat Kohli And Avneet Kaur Were At The Same Wimbledon Match, Finds Internet: "That's Why Virat…"

    July 9, 2025

    Censor Board Makes 150 Cuts To Udaipur Files, Film Based On Tailor Kanhaiya Lal's Murder

    July 9, 2025

    Superman First Review Calls James Gunn Film "Terrible" In Now-Deleted Post

    July 8, 2025
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    N24India
    • Home
    • Features
    • Politics

      Kashmir Attack Sparks Media Storm Amid Political Blame Game

      April 23, 2025

      Religious Bias Allegations Rock Amazon, eBay, and Oracle Customer Support many Companies.

      January 10, 2025

      Feroz Khan Addresses Controversy with AIMIM MLA, Calls for Improved Road Infrastructure in Asifnagar -N24india

      October 7, 2024

      Yati Narsinghanand Saraswati Sparks Outrage with Hate Speech Against Prophet Muhammad: Calls for Legal Action Intensify

      October 5, 2024

      Drugs, Baby Oil, Video Tools: What Went On At Rapper Diddy's "Freak Offs"

      September 23, 2024
    • Science
      1. Politics
      2. Lifestyle
      3. Sports
      4. View All

      Kashmir Attack Sparks Media Storm Amid Political Blame Game

      April 23, 2025

      Religious Bias Allegations Rock Amazon, eBay, and Oracle Customer Support many Companies.

      January 10, 2025

      Feroz Khan Addresses Controversy with AIMIM MLA, Calls for Improved Road Infrastructure in Asifnagar -N24india

      October 7, 2024

      Yati Narsinghanand Saraswati Sparks Outrage with Hate Speech Against Prophet Muhammad: Calls for Legal Action Intensify

      October 5, 2024

      Virat Kohli And Avneet Kaur Were At The Same Wimbledon Match, Finds Internet: "That's Why Virat…"

      July 9, 2025

      Censor Board Makes 150 Cuts To Udaipur Files, Film Based On Tailor Kanhaiya Lal's Murder

      July 9, 2025

      Superman First Review Calls James Gunn Film "Terrible" In Now-Deleted Post

      July 8, 2025

      Saiyaara Trailer: Ahaan Panday And Aneet Padda To Take Over Screens With Their Whirlwind Romance

      July 8, 2025

      Watch Weightlifting at Paris 2024 – Follow the Olympic Games

      July 15, 2024

      Charlotte Hornets Makes Career-high 34 Points in Loss to Utah Jazz

      July 15, 2024

      Young Teen Sucker-punches Opponent During Basketball Game

      March 12, 2021

      Bills’ Josh Allen Finishes Second in NFL Most Valuable Player Voting

      January 18, 2021

      World’s first electric hydrofoil ship is coming to Saudi Arabia’s NEOM

      August 21, 2024

      World’s Tiniest Fanged Frogs Lay Their Eggs on Leaves and Guard Them

      July 15, 2024

      Get this 4K HD Dual-Camera Drone with WiFi for $75

      July 15, 2024

      Russian Satellite Breaks up in Space, Forces ISS Astronauts to Shelter

      July 15, 2024
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    N24India
    Home»Politics»Opinion: The Economic Rationale For Amending The Waqf Act
    Politics

    Opinion: The Economic Rationale For Amending The Waqf Act

    AdminBy AdminAugust 19, 2024No Comments6 Mins Read
    Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
    Share
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email


    Imagine waking up to discover that your family’s ancestral land – where your roots run deep – has suddenly been claimed by someone else. This isn’t a plot twist from a novel but a real-life predicament faced by villagers in Tamil Nadu’s Thiruchendurai. Rajagopal, a farmer simply looking to sell a small piece of land, was told that his property now belonged to the Waqf Board. The sheer absurdity of the situation is reminiscent of a Kafka novel, where a certain machinery churns out decisions detached from reality.

    C.S. Lewis once wrote, “When you argue against Him you are arguing against the very power that makes you able to argue at all”. The landowners found themselves in a similarly paradoxical situation, unable to contest the very system that reclassified their land overnight. This farcical scenario shows the urgent need to amend the Waqf Act, which, as it stands, can transform long-held private land into Waqf property with the stroke of a pen, leaving rightful owners in the lurch.

    What Exactly Is A Waqf Property?

    A Waqf, under the Waqf Act of 1954, is a property irrevocably dedicated in the name of God for religious and charitable purposes, essentially rendering it non-transferable and perpetually detained as a charitable act towards God. Governed by the Waqf Act of 1995, Waqf properties-whether public or private-are managed by a ‘mutawali’ and overseen by state Waqf Boards, which wield significant power, including the ability to sanction transfers of immovable properties. Outlandishly, these properties, once designated as Waqf, are locked into perpetuity, immune to dissolution, and detached from broader legal frameworks, such as the Indian Trusts Act. The Waqf Board, a legal entity with sweeping authority, administers these properties, ensuring they serve the pious purposes they were intended for, and the Central Waqf Council advises and monitors these state-level boards.

    One of the major issues has been the broad powers granted to Waqf Boards, which have sometimes led to the controversial declaration of government and private properties as Waqf. For example, in Surat, the entire municipal corporation headquarters was declared as Waqf property, raising concerns about the overreach of the Waqf Board’s powers. Similar disputes have arisen in other parts of India, where properties with long histories have suddenly been declared Waqf, often leading to legal battles and public outcry.

    Lack Of Data And Documentation

    The lack of clear documentation and the potential for misuse of the Waqf Act have exacerbated these disputes. Courts have intervened in some cases, ruling that the Waqf Board must provide valid documentary evidence to support its claims. Despite these rulings, the expansive powers of the Waqf Boards continue to be a source of controversy.

    Waqf properties represent the third-largest landholding in India, only behind the Defence Ministry and Indian Railways. The Ministry of Minority Affairs has a portal that has digitised the data for these vast assets through the Waqf Assets Management System of India (WAMSI), part of the Qaumi Waqf Board Taraqqiati Scheme (QWBTS). This scheme aims to safeguard and prevent encroachment of Waqf properties through digitisation and GIS mapping. However, despite the entry of 8,72,324 immovable Waqf properties into WAMSI and the GIS mapping of 3,29,995 properties, a lot still needs to be done.

    According to the Waqf Management System of India (WAMSI), the status of Waqf properties shows significant management and documentation challenges. The largest category of properties, representing 436,169 units, has no information available, indicating a significant gap in data collection and transparency. Additionally, 58,898 properties are encroached upon, reflecting the extent of unauthorised occupation. There are also 7,831 properties under external litigation and 5,371 under internal litigation, highlighting the legal challenges faced in securing these assets. A substantial portion of properties, totalling 3,39,505, are non-encumbered. 

    How The System Has Led To Disputes

    The process of declaring a property as Waqf, particularly under the concept of “Waqf by use”, has led to numerous legal disputes. This ambiguity allows for conflicting claims between Waqf Boards and other stakeholders, including government agencies, leading to prolonged litigation and delays in the utilisation of these properties for charitable purposes.

    Further, the Waqf Act originally established tribunals to resolve disputes over Waqf properties. However, these tribunals are criticised for being inefficient and lacking judicial independence. Recent amendments have attempted to address this by modifying their composition, but concerns remain about their ability to handle complex property disputes effectively.

    What The Sachar Committee Said

    Several committees have raised issues with the Waqf Act. For instance, while introducing the Waqf Amendment Bill 2024 in Lok Sabha, the Minority Affairs Minister highlighted the 1976 Waqf inquiry report, which observed that Waqf properties were controlled by Mutawallis and called for corrective action. The report also recommended establishing a tribunal to resolve disputes and emphasised the need to fix improper audits and accounts of Waqf boards.

    The Sachar Committee flagged the issue of meagre revenue generation from Waqf properties. The report observed that annual income from Waqf properties (in 2005) across India was approximately ₹163 crore, representing a meagre rate of return of just 2.7%. The report suggests that if these properties were developed and put to efficient commercial use, they could generate at least a minimum return of 10%, translating to approximately ₹12,000 crores per annum.

    A Slew Of Regulatory Issues

    Historically, Waqf properties have faced significant challenges, including underutilisation, illegal encroachments, and widespread mismanagement, which have hindered their ability to generate much-needed revenue for the community. A lack of strategic planning, evident in the absence of comprehensive business plans, market analysis, and risk management strategies, has contributed to this issue. With insufficient monitoring and enforcement, regulatory oversight has been weak, allowing properties to be leased at below-market rates due to corruption. 

    Financial mismanagement has further compounded these problems, with funds often misappropriated or not reinvested effectively. Additionally, the lack of community involvement and oversight has led to decisions being made without adequate consultation, further alienating the intended beneficiaries. To overcome these challenges, it is essential to implement strict regulatory frameworks, enforce strategic business plans, and foster active community engagement, ensuring that Waqf properties are managed effectively and generate sustainable revenue for the community.
     
    Hence, reforms are needed. Despite attempts to bring order to the chaos, like digitising records, the system still feels like a Wild West of land claims.

    (Bibek Debroy is Chairman, Economic Advisory Council to the Prime Minister, and Aditya Sinha is OSD, Research, Economic Advisory Council to the Prime Minister)

    Disclaimer: These are the personal opinions of the author



    Original Source

    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
    Admin
    • Website

    Related Posts

    Kashmir Attack Sparks Media Storm Amid Political Blame Game

    April 23, 2025

    Religious Bias Allegations Rock Amazon, eBay, and Oracle Customer Support many Companies.

    January 10, 2025

    Feroz Khan Addresses Controversy with AIMIM MLA, Calls for Improved Road Infrastructure in Asifnagar -N24india

    October 7, 2024

    Comments are closed.

    Advertisement
    Demo
    Latest Posts

    Virat Kohli And Avneet Kaur Were At The Same Wimbledon Match, Finds Internet: "That's Why Virat…"

    July 9, 2025

    Censor Board Makes 150 Cuts To Udaipur Files, Film Based On Tailor Kanhaiya Lal's Murder

    July 9, 2025

    Superman First Review Calls James Gunn Film "Terrible" In Now-Deleted Post

    July 8, 2025

    Saiyaara Trailer: Ahaan Panday And Aneet Padda To Take Over Screens With Their Whirlwind Romance

    July 8, 2025
    Trending Posts
    Business & Economy

    Maersk CEO Vincent Clerc Speaks to ‘Massive Impact’ of the Red Sea Situation

    January 20, 2021
    Biotech

    These Knee Braces Help With Arthritis Pain, Swelling, and Post-Surgery Recovery

    January 15, 2021
    Sports

    Review: Can Wisconsin Clinch the Big Ten West this Weekend

    January 15, 2021

    Subscribe to News

    Get the latest sports news from NewsSite about world, sports and politics.

    Your source for the serious news. This demo is crafted specifically to exhibit the use of the theme as a news site. Visit our main page for more demos.

    We're social. Connect with us:

    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram Pinterest YouTube

    Subscribe to Updates

    Get the latest creative news from FooBar about art, design and business.

    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram Pinterest
    • Home
    • Hyderabad
    • Telengana
    • Lifestyle
      • Science
    • Politics
      • Asia
      • Europe
      • World
    • Middle East
    • Sports
    • Home
    • Blog
    • Homepage
    • Typography Elements
    • Get In Touch
    • Our Authors
    © 2025 ThemeSphere. Designed by ThemeSphere.

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.